Motus RecruitingMotus RecruitingMotus RecruitingMotus Recruiting
  • DIVERSITY
    • MISSION
    • ASSOCIATIONS
    • PARTNER
    • DIVERSITY BLOG
  • SEARCH JOBS
  • EMPLOYERS
    • OUR PROCESS
    • OUR SOLUTIONS
  • EXECUTIVE SEARCH
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • MEET THE TEAM
    • OUR SPECIALTIES
      • ACCOUNTING & FINANCE
      • PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
      • TECHNOLOGY
  • RESOURCES
    • BLOG
    • EVENTS
  • CONNECT

BLOG
NextPrevious
Working

How to Assess Competing Job Offers

By Motus Recruiting | All Topics, Job Seeker’s Guide | 14 May, 2018

With so many opportunities in the job market these days, many job seekers are receiving more than one job offer. If this is you, you might find yourself in unchartered waters. How are you supposed to know which job is the right one? What factors should you be taking into consideration besides simply which company is offering the highest salary? It’s hard to look past the hourly pay when companies are finally loosening up and being more competitive with compensation!

There are several factors to consider when weighing the value of a job offer, including benefits, environment and culture, perks, growth prospects, and logistics. Picking the right job may seem like a daunting task, but there are a few explainable steps that can help you chart those waters.

Step 1: Desirables and Priorities

Contrary to what you might think, this whole process actually starts with you, not the offer. Before you take into consideration what the company is offering, you need to draft a list of “Desirables and Priorities.” This step can happen before you even take the interview, but it should certainly happen before an offer is made; you need to know what you want and need first. Once you complete your list, you can use it to assess and compare offers; see which offers fulfill those desires, and also which items the offers did not meet and decide how important those things are.

Step 2: Assess the Offer

Now it’s time to look at the company and everything that comes with the job. There are some important questions, aside from pay, that you should be asking when you’ve come to this step.

Benefits:

  • What are the benefits? What all is included and paid for?
  • Have you heard good things about their insurance providers?
  • What percentage of the premiums will the company pay? How much will be out of pocket each month?
  • Do they offer a comprehensive Employee Assistance Program, Aflac and/or a Cafeteria Plan/HSA?
  • Do they offer any paid life insurance?
  • Do they offer a 401K or IRA and do they match?
  • Do they offer long and short term disability?
  • Do they offer any kind of signing bonus or relocation package?

Taking time to understand your benefits package is imperative as it is a large piece of the offer as a whole. If you have dependents, this could potentially be an even more important factor, so be sure to ask questions and understand your benefits before accepting the job.

Environment/Culture:

Environment is quickly becoming a factor that rivals salary. Studies show that more and more people are willing to compromise on salary in exchange for a desirable work culture under the reasoning that you should “love where you work.” Culture fit is an important factor when considering an offer, because it often correlates to longevity within the company.

  • What was the feel of the company when you interviewed and toured?
  • What matters to the leadership, what are their core values, and do they live them?
  • Do they offer volunteering hours to their employees or give back in ways that are important to you?
  • Are they a Green operation?
  • What are the other team members like and how is the retention rate?
  • Do they make time to celebrate and build relationships within their teams?
  • Do they acknowledge the wins?
  • What are their Glassdoor reviews like?

Be sure to read ALL the Glassdoor reviews, and look at the whole picture. You will want to balance between knowing that you’ll have your own experience and identifying repetitive issues within the reviews. It will be important to assess the company based on your intuition as well as with research.

Growth and Logistics:

  • Do they encourage growth and development for their employees?
  • Does the opportunity offer you a happy career for more than a year or 2?
  • Do they offer structure yet some flexibility as well?
  • What are the perks of working there?
  • What will your commute be like every day to and from work?
  • Do they offer subsidized transportation or parking?

Looking at these questions, you can understand how salary is only one piece of the pie. You should have a figure that you would be comfortable with in terms of salary, but money only goes so far and lasts so long in terms of the whole offer. If you are offered a higher salary but don’t have much growth potential, 3 years down the road can look completely different there than with another company who career tracks their employees or offers commissions and bonuses. You might be offered generous pay, but if the culture of the company doesn’t fit your personality you might end up leaving in less than a year. Taking the time to answer these questions is an important step in considering the offer.

Step 3: Pros and Cons

A simple ‘Pros and Cons’ list is a very effective approach. You have gathered all the information, answered all of the questions about benefits, culture, and logistics, and now you have the data to compare to your initial ‘Desirables and Priorities’ list. Creating a Pros and Cons list for each offer you receive should give you clear, comparable data points that should lead you to an informed decision.

Step 4: Consult an Expert

A final step to consider would be to speak with an expert in the marketplace, such as a Career Coach or a trusted Recruiter. They can be an objective opinion for you and may know things that you don’t, and ask you questions that will help you determine the best choice. When you are working with a Recruiter, it will be very important for you to share the lists you’ve made with them so they can look through the correct lens while assisting you in your search. It is important for recruiters to consider the right things for you, and to know what value you put on each desire so we can match you to all of the opportunities that best fulfil your career goals, short and long term.

The key to making an informed career decision is to look at salary as a piece of the offer, rather than as the entire offer. Being prepared and knowing what you need from a job will help you sort through the opportunities that you are offered.

No tags.

Related Post

  • Interviewing Lost in Thought

    How to Recover from Losing Your Train of Thought in an Interview

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    Losing your train of thought is an inevitable part of public speaking, but there are few situations as high pressure as an interview. In fact, the adrenaline rush of an interview can actually cause youRead more

  • Phone on a Table

    Seven Tips for an Effective Phone Interview

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    Phone interviews sound great, right? No commuting, no fancy outfit, sweaty palms, or done up hair– sounds perfect! Well, not quite. As easy as they may seem, phone interviews should be taken just as seriously,Read more

  • Interviewing Nervously

    Five Telltale Signs That Give Away Your Nerves

    By Kariann Gillis | Comments are Closed

    Your palms are sweaty, your mind is racing, you can hear the pitter-patter of your foot shaking, and you find yourself wondering, “Am I being obvious? Can they tell I’m nervous?” In short, yes, allRead more

  • People Celebrating

    Five Professional Networking Tips for Events

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    Five tips that will take you from a networking newbie to a networking Rockstar. 1. Do your research Make sure that you do your research on the event that you are attending. Check out theRead more

  • Laughing During a Meeting

    Find a Job That Inspires You and Avoid the Sunday Scaries

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    Have you ever experienced a case of the ‘Sunday Scaries’? Perhaps your Sunday starts out slowly, with a cup of coffee and intentions of relaxation, but as the day progresses and you think about theRead more

  • Handshake Over Table

    What Are the Benefits of Using a Recruiter?

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    Everyone knows that looking for your dream job, or just any job, can be full time work. With so many challenges that come up when searching for a new position, job seekers face a varietyRead more

  • Handshake

    Navigating the Employment Gap Question as an Interviewer

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    Are you a Hiring Manager looking to grow your team? You might be in the interview process, meeting with several candidates, and then you come across a candidate with a gap in their employment. IfRead more

  • Mom and Children With a Tablet

    Four Tips From a Working Mother

    By Motus Recruiting | Comments are Closed

    As a working mom, sometimes it can be very overwhelming to juggle a full-time job and take care of your kids. It’s a big challenge to find balance in my daily routine as a workingRead more

NextPrevious
Submit a Question
Our Diversity Blog

Topics

  • All Topics
  • Career Coaching
  • Community Conversations
  • Company Culture
  • Diversity and Inclusion
  • Hiring Manager’s Guide
  • Job Seeker’s Guide
  • Leadership
  • Miscellaneous
  • Motus News

Authors

  • Angela Gatewood
  • Emma Osborne
  • Kariann Gillis
  • Lyssa Kohnke
  • Mike Betts
  • Motus Recruiting
  • Orlando Williams
  • Patrick David

QUICK LINKS

Search Jobs
Blog
Employers

ABOUT US

Diversity
Our Story
Meet The Team

CONTACT US

6650 SW Redwood Lane
Suite 355
Tigard, Oregon 97224
Phone: 503.496.1310

FOLLOW US

© 2018 Motus Recruiting & Staffing | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy
  • DIVERSITY
    • MISSION
    • ASSOCIATIONS
    • PARTNER
    • DIVERSITY BLOG
  • SEARCH JOBS
  • EMPLOYERS
    • OUR PROCESS
    • OUR SOLUTIONS
  • EXECUTIVE SEARCH
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • MEET THE TEAM
    • OUR SPECIALTIES
      • ACCOUNTING & FINANCE
      • PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
      • TECHNOLOGY
  • RESOURCES
    • BLOG
    • EVENTS
  • CONNECT
Motus Recruiting